How to Build Your Classroom Discipline Philosophy as a Student Teacher

Chapter 29 is about discipline, and why the approach that works for you has to match who you are. It is for student teachers who worry about what they will do the first time a student pushes back. It follows Chapter 28 on classroom management, and if an interviewer asks how you handle a disruptive student, this post on that question shows how to turn your philosophy into an answer.

This is Chapter 29 of 51 from Road to Teaching (2025 edition). Read the whole book free, in order, at Read the Book.

By Dr. Eric Hougan

“Know thyself.”Scribes of Delphi, via Plato

Classroom discipline is another robust topic that cannot be thoroughly examined in a book of this size. Nevertheless, the subject needs to be addressed because it is on the mind of practically every novice teacher. All educators know that at some point, no matter how great of a teacher you may be, discipline problems will arise. Since all teachers inevitably face discipline challenges, how you handle them is critical to your professional growth. To establish a successful discipline policy, you will need a framework to work within. Construct this discipline framework by reflecting on your discipline philosophy, and developing an understanding of the school rules, policies, and procedures.

Reflect on Your Discipline Philosophy

Begin by reviewing your education philosophy statement and asking yourself these questions:

  • What values in your education philosophy translate into your beliefs about discipline?
  • Does your discipline philosophy include such values as fairness, dignity, and equity?
  • Using five adjectives, how would you describe your classroom discipline philosophy?

Jot down your ideas and begin drafting your discipline philosophy. Your discipline philosophy will allow you to build on your strengths and beliefs to maintain order in your classroom while ensuring the dignity of your students.

While you are doing this exercise, also ask yourself if you are going to be democratic, authoritarian, or moderate in your discipline approach. For example, if you are by nature laid-back and you desire a democratic approach to classroom management and discipline, then taking on the role as an authoritarian will be exhausting and self-defeating. Since you will probably not be able to maintain that authoritarian mask, the students may hear the authoritarian verbal tone but receive a very different (mixed) message from your non-verbal cues. The possible anxiety and confusion caused by mixed signals may lead to classroom management issues.

In short, mixed signals, and the classroom misbehavior that may result, can be avoided by establishing a classroom discipline philosophy and approach that is consistent with who you are. And this is accomplished through on-going self-reflection.

Contemporary approaches to discipline emphasize restorative rather than punitive practices. Consider how your philosophy aligns with research-based approaches such as:

  • Restorative justice: Focus on repairing harm and rebuilding relationships rather than just imposing consequences
  • Positive behavior interventions and supports (PBIS): Emphasize teaching and reinforcing appropriate behaviors
  • Trauma-informed practices: Understand that some student behaviors may stem from trauma or adverse experiences
  • Culturally responsive discipline: Recognize that different cultural backgrounds may influence student behavior and communication styles

Your discipline philosophy should also address how you’ll handle the emotional aspects of discipline situations. Teaching is inherently emotional work, and discipline moments can trigger strong feelings in both teachers and students. Consider:

  • How will you remain calm and professional when students challenge your authority?
  • What strategies will you use to de-escalate tense situations?
  • How will you separate the behavior from the child when addressing problems?
  • What support systems will you seek when facing particularly challenging situations?

Know the School Rules, Policies, and Procedures

A second and relatively easy step to take to ease your discipline anxiety is to know the rules, policies, and procedures of the school. Begin your research by reviewing the school’s handbook to become familiar with its stated policies. Many schools have electronic versions of their handbooks posted on their websites. If you cannot locate one online then ask your cooperating teacher or school administration for a copy.

The handbook is a valuable resource for information on schedules, mission and belief statements, staff contacts, technology, and emergency guidelines, as well as discipline. It should provide a sufficient explanation of school policies on the following:

  • Classroom infractions
  • Dress code
  • Drugs & alcohol
  • Due process
  • Insubordination
  • Physical and verbal abuse
  • Tardiness and absences
  • Weapons

Beyond the written policies, take time to understand the school’s discipline culture through observation and conversation. Notice:

  • How do teachers typically handle minor disruptions?
  • What is the process for referring students to administration?
  • How are parents typically involved in discipline situations?
  • What support services are available for students with ongoing behavioral challenges?
  • How does the school balance accountability with support for struggling students?

Pay particular attention to any school-wide behavior management systems in place. Many schools now use programs like PBIS, Character Counts, or other frameworks that provide consistent approaches across all classrooms. Understanding these systems will help you align your individual classroom practices with broader school expectations.

Also familiarize yourself with legal requirements related to discipline, particularly regarding students with disabilities. Students with Individualized Education Programs (IEPs) or 504 plans may have specific behavioral supports or modified discipline procedures that you need to understand and follow.

Being intentional about how your discipline philosophy and having a richer understanding of the rules and policies in the school are valuable starting points to grow your ability to have an orderly and dignified classroom environment.

Lastly, know that, as with every other aspect in teaching, your discipline philosophy and approach may change over time based on new experiences. Based on your learnings and growth as an educator and the group students in front of you, you may need (or want to) refine your discipline philosophy and approach.

Consider keeping a reflection journal specifically focused on discipline situations you observe or experience. Document:

  • What happened and how it was handled
  • What worked well and what could have been improved
  • How different students responded to various approaches
  • Questions you have about discipline situations
  • Insights you’re gaining about your own discipline style

This ongoing reflection will help you continuously refine your approach and build confidence in handling challenging situations. Remember that becoming skilled at classroom discipline is a process that develops over time through experience, reflection, and continued learning.

Key Takeaway

Develop a discipline approach that aligns with your authentic values and the school’s policies, focusing on restorative practices that maintain student dignity while promoting learning. Understanding yourself and your approach to discipline helps you respond consistently and effectively to challenging situations.

Interviewing soon? See how this chapter turns into an answer: How Do You Handle Disruptive Students?

Road to Teaching book cover
The whole road

Want the whole road in your bag?

All 51 chapters plus 100+ interview questions, from your first education course to your first contract. Paperback $12.99, Kindle $7.99 on Amazon.

Previous
Previous

Parent Communication for Student Teachers: Think Customer Service

Next
Next

Classroom Management for Student Teachers: Bell Work, Withitness, and More