How to Show Student Growth in Student Teaching (Build Your Touchstone)

Chapter 31 is about building a touchstone during student teaching: one clear, measured example of how you improved student learning. It is for student teachers who want something concrete to talk about when a principal asks about their impact. It follows Chapter 30 on working with parents, and it builds on Chapter 17 on setting student teaching goals.

This is Chapter 31 of 51 from Road to Teaching (2025 edition). Read the whole book free, in order, at Read the Book.

By Dr. Eric Hougan

“Desire is the key to motivation, but it’s determination and commitment to an unrelenting pursuit of your goal—a commitment to excellence—that will enable you to attain the success you seek.”Mario Andretti

As previously discussed throughout this section, your student teaching experience will present you with numerous opportunities to differentiate yourself from fellow teacher candidates. Another great way to further set yourself apart is by establishing a touchstone as you enter student teaching. A touchstone is a standard by which something is judged. Therefore, the touchstone you establish should be a standard of excellence that is used to improve targeted student learning, through instruction or a curriculum, and that is easily transferable to another school.

In today’s schools, you will find there is a strong emphasis on student achievement, and therefore school administrators are seeking out job candidates that can effectively plan, instruct, and assess, as well as being reflective of their pedagogy. Administrators are looking for specific examples of how you have improved student learning and ways you could incorporate those same practices to make a positive impact on student learning in their schools. As you embark on student teaching, consider these tips in creating your touchstone.

Identify Areas of Improvement

In establishing your touchstone, you should begin by focusing most of your effort in improving one particular area. Use student data, such as student work or school-wide standardized testing, to determine your focus area.

For example, let us imagine that you have scrutinized your school’s recent standardized test scores. You notice that in the areas of writing and math, the students’ scores have progressed significantly from last year. However, the reading scores showed only slight improvement and continue to lag behind the district and state average scores. From this data, you resolve to incorporate reading skills in your curriculum in hopes of increasing students’ reading comprehension, and, ultimately, the students’ test results.

Contemporary data sources extend beyond standardized test scores. Consider examining:

  • Formative assessment data from classroom activities
  • Student engagement surveys or observations
  • Social-emotional learning indicators
  • Behavior referral patterns
  • Student work samples and portfolio assessments
  • Parent and student feedback about learning experiences

When identifying your focus area, ensure it aligns with:

  • School improvement goals and initiatives
  • Your cooperating teacher’s priorities
  • Your own areas of professional interest and strength
  • Realistic timeframes for implementation and measurement

Establish a Baseline

The next step is to establish a starting point (a baseline) for your area of improvement. This step of having a baseline assessment will 1) determine the skill level in your particular classroom, and 2) create a standard through which you can measure progress. In short, understanding your baseline will allow you to measure your students’ growth.

Here are some assessment approaches to determine a baseline on the students’ learning and skill level:

  • Teacher-Student Interview/Conferences
  • Classroom-based assessments (e.g., quizzes and tests)
  • Sample student work
  • Surveys
  • Standardized tests
  • Student reflections
  • Teacher observations

Digital tools can enhance baseline data collection:

  • Online surveys using Google Forms or similar platforms
  • Learning management system analytics showing student engagement patterns
  • Digital portfolios that track student progress over time
  • Video observations that can be analyzed for specific behaviors or skills
  • Apps that track reading levels, math fluency, or other specific skills

Illustrative Example

Imagine you quizzed your students on an article they just read. After the quiz, you survey the students by asking them to identify the different reading strategies they employed while reading the article. Your survey lists various best-practice reading strategies with descriptive examples and the students mark the ones they used. From the collected surveys, you build your baseline by formulating some quantitative findings. For instance, you determine that only 15% of your students use two or more of the best-practice reading strategies. In addition, 65% of the students indicated they had “difficulty” in comprehending the article.

Next, you grade the quizzes and find a class average score of 62%. The survey findings shed some light as to why the students scored poorly on the reading comprehension quiz. You realize that the students use very few reading strategies to improve their comprehension and this is reflected in their assessments.

The good news is that you have a clearer view of the problem and you have a measurable baseline (the quantitative analysis) to determine if using reading strategies will improve the students’ reading comprehension.

Build Your Touchstone

As a first step in building your touchstone, you must become a reflective problem-solver. Begin by brainstorming different ways to tackle the problem of improving your students’ baseline. Consider incorporating best practices learned in your teacher education training.

Another great way for figuring out how to implement effective strategies is in collaborating with other teachers. For instance, if improving reading comprehension were my focus then I would partner up with the Language Arts teachers or reading specialists to investigate effective reading strategies.

There are other means to generate your plan of action:

  • Reading literature
  • Researching educational journals
  • Observing classrooms in which students are exhibiting proficiency in your area of improvement
  • Partnering with your local university
  • Attending professional development workshops
  • Searching the Internet

Digital resources have expanded research possibilities:

  • Educational podcasts featuring expert interviews and case studies
  • Webinars and virtual conferences
  • Online professional learning communities
  • Social media groups focused on specific educational topics
  • YouTube channels featuring classroom demonstrations
  • Research databases and educational blogs

Once you have determined the best practice instructional strategies and/or changes to make in your curriculum, the next step is implementation.

For instance, referencing back to the earlier reading comprehension example, you may begin to teach the students how to monitor their reading comprehension, employ “fix-it” strategies when the students’ comprehension falls off, and introduce additional tools discovered during your research. Document your implementation process carefully:

  • Keep a reflection journal about what’s working and what isn’t
  • Take photos or videos (with permission) of student work and engagement
  • Collect student feedback about new strategies
  • Track both quantitative and qualitative data
  • Note any unexpected challenges or successes

Soon after implementation, monitor and evaluate your plan of action to see if what you are doing is influencing the bottom-line: your students’ learning. Using the same assessment tools (in this example, a survey, and quiz) you develop a quantitative analysis. Compared to the baseline, have the students shown any significant improvement in your targeted area of improvement, e.g., reading comprehension?

Lastly, as you gather formative evidence, be reflective and regularly modify your plan of action to get even greater results. Consider additional support and feedback you could provide students that are not experiencing the expected level of growth in their learning.

Communicating Your Touchstone

If you are able to accomplish this feat during your already hectic student teaching time, then consider yourself are a teaching rock star. And, you have a concrete example of student improvement to discuss at future job interviews. In such discussions, articulate the steps you took: collecting and analyzing the data, setting student-focused learning goals, researching the methodology, implementing your plan, to evaluating and reflecting on the results.

Describe how this process impacted student learning by providing a mix of qualitative and quantitative findings.

Finally, show how the expectations you set at the school where you were as a student teacher could be applicable to other schools. For instance, “Reviewing the state tests, I [the job candidate] noticed the students’ reading scores at your [principal’s] school are similar to the school where I was a student teacher. I strongly believe I would be able to deliver the same improvements in reading comprehension to ABC School as I did in XYZ School.”

In summary, having a touchstone of excellence will greatly enhance your chances of being hired in the school you desire. When presenting your touchstone in interviews, prepare:

  • A clear, concise narrative about the problem you identified
  • Specific data that demonstrates student growth
  • Student work samples that illustrate improvement
  • Reflection on what you learned from the process
  • Plans for how you would adapt the approach in a new setting

Your touchstone should demonstrate several key competencies that administrators value:

  • Data-driven decision making
  • Research-based practice implementation
  • Student-centered focus
  • Reflective practice and continuous improvement
  • Ability to measure and communicate impact
  • Transferable skills and strategies

Remember that your touchstone doesn’t have to show dramatic results to be valuable. What matters most is your systematic approach to identifying needs, implementing solutions, and measuring progress. This process demonstrates the kind of thoughtful, evidence-based practice that effective teachers use throughout their careers.

Key Takeaway

Document a specific example of how you identified student needs, implemented evidence-based strategies, and measured improvement during your student teaching. This concrete evidence of your impact on student learning will distinguish you in job interviews and demonstrate your ability to make a difference in any school setting.

Road to Teaching book cover
The whole road

Want the whole road in your bag?

All 51 chapters plus 100+ interview questions, from your first education course to your first contract. Paperback $12.99, Kindle $7.99 on Amazon.